A Long Post About a Lost (?) TV Pilot

Years ago, a great many short-lived TV shows and unsold pilots came from a simple thought: What if we combined the formats of a situation comedy and a variety show?  Someone said to someone, "It'll be an hour like most variety shows and there will be songs and dancing every six or eight minutes like on a variety show…but instead of comedy sketches in-between, we'll have short stories or chapters of stories like on a sitcom with a little coterie of regular characters!"

I guess in the meetings, it sounded like a great idea but I can't think of an attempt that resulted in a successful, ongoing TV series.  I can, however, think of a lot of times when it was tried and it failed.  Here are just a few examples…

In the early seventies, there was a series called The Funny Side created by Bill Persky and Sam Denoff, two of the main writers on successful sitcoms like The Dick Van Dyke Show and That Girl.  But The Funny Side — an hour-long sitcom with songs –didn't last long.  Neither did The Brady Bunch Variety Hour or a couple of other pilots my frequent employers Sid and Marty Krofft attempted.

Neither did That's Life! starring Robert Morse in an attempt to do an hour-long musical comedy each week.  Jackie Gleason briefly had some success trying to do weekly musicals with some Honeymooners episodes but they petered out.

When The Dean Martin Show was running out of gas, its producer — Greg Garrison — experimented with a format that had Dean running a swank nightclub with funny little mini-sitcom scenes between musical performances. Didn't work.  When Mary Tyler Moore tried to make a comeback in a variety show format, they tried weaving a storyline between song and dance numbers. Didn't work.

George Schlatter produced an hour of Li'l Abner with various actors portraying the characters from Al Capp's famous newspaper strip.  Sometimes, they'd be signing and dancing.  Sometimes, they'd be doing short sitcom-type segments.  The only good thing that came of that attempt was that my partner Sergio Aragonés was hired to design some of the cartoony sets and because of that, he met an actress-dancer named Charlene Ryan who was playing Stupefyin' Jones. The Li'l Abner sitcom/variety show disappeared quickly but Sergio and Charlene have now been happily married for several decades.

There were other attempts before the TV industry gave up on variety shows with or without sitcom elements. I was only involved — slightly — with one attempt. In 1976 when I was a story editor on Welcome Back, Kotter, its producer Jimmie Komack made two pilots that tried to build one of those sitcom/variety hybrids out of the Archie comic books. You know: Archie, Betty, Veronica, Jughead, Reggie, et al.  Those characters.

Komack had this odd notion of how to approach doing an adaptation of an existing property. His view was that it should be done by writers and producers who were completely unfamiliar with the source material. That way, their minds were uncluttered by what had been done before. While I was working for him, he also tried it with a spectacularly unsuccessful pure sitcom revival of Dobie Gillis that didn't much resemble the old Dobie Gillis.

The folks on the creative staff engaged for Archie were not totally unfamiliar with the property. How could they be?  Still, Komack insisted they not read the old comics and instead work from a rough outline someone had written about who the characters were.  His goal was not to replicate comic books.  He wanted to reinvent the franchise for television, the better to make it appeal to the zillions of viewers that didn't know and love the comics.  Somehow — I know not how — John Goldwater got worried about what "those TV people" were doing to the property on which his whole company rested.

John L. Goldwater — a distant relative of Barry, I've heard — was the founder of the Archie company and I'm not sure if he was the owner or co-owner then but he certainly was the man to please.  He also considered himself the creator of the Archie property.  Some historians will tell you otherwise but there would be a credit line of this show that said "Based on the comic strip characters created by John Goldwater."  He'd been quite happy with the various Archie cartoon shows that were coming out of the Filmation Studio.  He arranged a visit to Komack's office hoping to be assured he'd be happy with the live-action version.

The first I heard of this possible problem was when Jimmie summoned me — and only me, not me and my writing partner Dennis Palumbo — to his office.  He asked me, "You know all about comic books, don't you?" I said I did. He said, "Archie Comics?" I said I did.  "Good," he said.  "A man named John Goldwater is coming by later today and I'd like you to be in the meeting."

Later that day in the meeting, Jimmie introduced me as one of his best writers — the only time I ever heard him say anything like that — and said I was a world-class expert at Archie history.  Without saying it directly, he gave Mr. Goldwater the idea that I was one of the writers on the Archie pilot (I wasn't) and that I was making sure everything on it would be faithful to Mr. Goldwater's vision.  I wasn't doing that, either.  Then Jimmie asked me to demonstrate how much I knew about Archie.

I felt I had to play along with this role I had been cast in without my consent.  I explained to Mr. Goldwater that I'd written many comic books and that I'd apprenticed with Jack Kirby. Mr. Goldwater was impressed at the mention of Jack, who'd worked for his company a few times. We spoke for a few minutes and somehow, I managed to wedge in a nice nugget of trivia.

Kotter had just begun sharing its stage  with a new ABC sitcom called Fish, a spin-off of Barney Miller that I don't believe was on the air yet.  It starred Abe Vigoda and I mentioned that Abe Vigoda's brother Bill Vigoda had been a top artist for Archie. "Is that true?" Jimmie asked, incredulously. Goldwater nodded it was true…and that seemed to convince him that I would make sure that Archie on TV was the Archie of the comic books and that Betty would be Betty and Veronica would be Veronica and so forth.

I don't recall that I actually said anything about the casting or the format or the script — none of which I'd seen — but Mr. Goldwater seemed somehow reassured.  And since he seemed to be that, Jimmie decided to quit while he was ahead and send me back to work on Kotter.  I never got to talk further with Mr. Goldwater. Later, Jimmie did consult with me on a number of points including some of the final casting — but I didn't write on the first pilot nor was I credited or compensated in any way.

At the time, I was annoyed that he'd tapped me for so much expertise without offering work or money or anything. Later on, I was happy not to have the failure on my résumé.  That left plenty of room on it for the failures on which I actually worked.

Komack's Archie pilots starred Audrey Landers as Betty, Hilary Thompson as Veronica, Mark Winkworth as Reggie, Derrel Maury as Jughead, Jane Lambert as Miss Grundy, Susan Blu as Midge, Jim Boelson as Moose, Whit Bissell as Mr. Lodge, Michelle Stacy as Little Jinx, Tifni Twitchell as Big Ethel and Amzie Strickland as Mrs. Lodge. Byron Webster played Mr. Weatherbee and Gordon Jump played Archie's father.

You may be familiar with Gordon Jump from his role later on WKRP in Cincinnati or his years as the Maytag washing machine repairman in commercials. He came in to audition for Mr. Weatherbee and got the part. Then, since the producers couldn't properly cast the role of Archie's father, they moved Jump to that slot and put their second-choice in as Mr. Weatherbee. No one thought to tell Mr. Jump when the final shooting scripts were delivered so on the first day of rehearsal, he showed up with the wrong role memorized.

Who played the title role of Archie Andrews? Well, that's an interesting story in itself. After extensive auditions and screen tests, they picked a young man with brilliant red hair but no real acting experience, at least on television. Somehow, things didn't work out in the contract phase. I never heard exactly what happened but suddenly, the morning of the day rehearsals commenced, the role of Archie was being played by the producers' second choice. It was an actor named Dennis Bowen who had appeared a few times on Kotter in the recurring role of Todd Ludlow, an honors student who clashed with the "teen" characters on the series.

That's Dennis Bowen with the naturally-red hair.

Somehow, the ABC publicity department never got the word and all the p.r. they issued for the show contained the name of the first actor, the one who was replaced. Poor Dennis Bowen had to endure publicity photos that displayed his face but identified him as the first guy. Years later when the Archie comic book folks published a book on the character's history, they said the first guy had played the role. The first guy was David Caruso, later known for his roles as Detective John Kelly on NYPD Blue and Lieutenant Horatio Caine on CSI: Miami, among other credits.

He was fortunate to be out of it too. The show was a mess for many reasons. It was being targeted for the 7:00 Sunday evening slot and I recall a lot of argument over how many scenes there could be of Betty, Veronica and a number of good-looking female extras in swimwear and sleepwear. The writers had scripted several quick jokes at a swimming pool, and one of the short stories involved the boys crashing a slumber party that Veronica was throwing at the Lodge mansion. Both had been planned expressly to get the ladies into scanty outfits, which the ABC programming department encouraged.

For some reason, the actor playing Moose was dressed as Charlie Brown.

At the same time, their Standards and Practices folks ran around demanding less-revealing bikinis and nighties. Some of the best jokes in the show wound up being cut because the ladies were showing a half-inch too much of their physiques.  This kind of thing mattered a lot on TV shows, B.C.  That means "Before Cable."

By the way: If you ever produce a TV show and want to have a mob of male crew members hanging around on the set, just have scenes where a lot of actresses are in sexy nightgowns.  The stage was packed with men those days, all standing around debating who was cuter — Betty or Veronica.

Like all these hybrid variety-sitcoms, there were blackouts and little, self-contained storylines of a few minutes each. Between these, the focus would shift to a rather generic rock band that played bubble-gum style music. But the sitcom-type scenes were too short to really get to know the characters and the generic rock band was not very good and utterly irrelevant to the Archie characters. The show was shot with no studio audience and the network execs particularly hated the overly-delighted laugh track. It was quickly declared DOA at ABC well before it aired on December 19. 1976.  I never heard what John Goldwater thought of it but I would guess he was undelighted.

Notice the great time slot it was given.

That would have been the end of it but Komack's agents — he had great agents — had forced the deal to be for two pilots so Jimmie had another shot at it. I recall some bickering and delays as ABC decided they didn't want a second pilot and tried to buy or trade their way out of that commitment but Komack wasn't giving up. A month or two later, production started on that second pilot. The cast would be the same. The sitcom elements would be lengthened. The generic rock band would be replaced by the Archie characters themselves singing and dancing, even though those actors had not been chosen for any musical abilities. The laugh track would not get overly hysterical over every line of dialogue.

By this time, we'd finished the season on Welcome Back, Kotter and I had my agent tell the Komack people I did not want to return for another year. I was on to other things and was surprised when I was offered a job writing on that second pilot. Komack had decided to try the wild and crazy idea of having someone writing on this version who'd actually read an Archie comic book and I may have been the only person he knew who fit that qualification.

I guess I was kind of hired but we never closed a deal and I left after two days of meetings with Danny Simon, brother of Neil, who had been hired as Head Writer. Danny was a delightful, funny gent but he had a vast knowledge of old, tried-and-true comedy sketches from fifties television.  I just noticed and fixed a typo in the previous sentence where I'd typed "tired-and-true" but that also applied.  Anyway, Danny's idea of writing this second pilot was taking those old sketches and making one character in them be Archie and another character would be Veronica and so on.

It's all a little fuzzy today but I remember calling my agent, telling him I wanted out and he said something like, "I'll see what I can do but don't report to the studio until we get this settled." And then the show was never mentioned again and it went ahead without me…to the same fate as Pilot #1.

At some point during the above paragraphs, you probably got to wondering why I was telling you all this now. I have a reason — maybe not a good one but it is a reason.

Since those two pilots crashed and burned, I've been kinda looking for a recording of one or the other…and so have some of the people who were involved, in front of or behind the camera. I've run into many of them and no one had a copy of it. Well now, they can, sort of. Someone has uploaded an imperfect recording of Pilot #1 to this thing we call an Internet. There are a few bad edits in it but here it is. See if you think ABC made a bonehead mistake by not immediately giving it a full season pickup.  I am in no way responsible for any part of this.  I was just on the premises, especially when they were taping the scene with the girls in nightgowns.