Whenever I have been with Jonathan Winters, it's been the same: Everyone around stops and tells him, "You are the funniest man who ever lived." Sometimes, they go on and on about how often they've played his albums, how much they loved him in this or that movie or on some TV show. Often, unaware of the insensitivity in their questions, they ask him why he isn't on TV more often and/or how he feels about so many other performers — Robin Williams, especially — borrowing material from the fertile Winters imagination.
It is also not uncommon for people to try and coax him into a little improvisation, throwing some question at him that just might provoke him to lapse into character. Depending on his mood, Jonathan may or may not comply. I once stood on Cahuenga Boulevard for twenty minutes and watched him turn into an ambassador from some nation with indeterminate dialects, spewing paranoid fantasies about other countries, their ambassadors and, for some reason, the ambassadors' house pets. It was as funny as anything I ever heard on TV, only I didn't hear it on TV. I heard it on Cahuenga, in front of a French restaurant.
Mr. Winters is not the only human being I've been around who is incessantly called the funniest comedian ever. When I worked with Sid Caesar, everyone who passed would stop and tell him the same thing. I've always wondered how it was on the set of It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World with not just the funniest man in the world but two of them. (And they also had Buster Keaton and a few other contenders around…)
Still, Jonathan is one of a kind. In a lifetime of talking comedy and comedians, I have never encountered anyone who mentioned his name and was not in awe of his mind, his characterizations, his sheer ability to pull funny out of thin air. The talent is truly organic. You could quote most comics' acts and get at least some of the laughs. With Winters, you have to be there. It's only wonderful when he says it and often, only when he says it.
He's eighty years old today. Here's hoping he and Sid both go on being the Funniest Man Alive for a long time.