This Evening

Going to see Lewis Black do stand-up. Hope he's Fair and Balanced. Full report later.

Briefly Noted…

Fox News may be "Fair and Balanced" but no one in their website division apparently made contingency plans for a power outage. It has now been almost two hours since portions of the East Coast lost all electricity. All the other major news sites — some of which must be based in that area — had bulletins up within fifteen minutes. The Fox News site still doesn't have a word about it.

About What's Up, Tiger Lily?

Earlier, I mentioned that What's Up, Tiger Lily? had been released to DVD and that I wished they'd been able to include the original soundtrack as Alternate Audio. This prompted e-mail buddy Pierce Askegren to write to me last night and say…

Are you aware that there are three soundtracks for the movie? The Anchor Bay VHS cassette some years back used a different dub track, with noticeably different versions of some gags. According to the Video Watchdog review at the time, the differences are pervasive enough that it's not a case of something being edited for broadcast, but a legit, alternate version. No one seems to know why.

I knew nothing about this but I knew who might. I dropped an e-mail to Frank Buxton, who was one of the writer-performers behind What's Up, Tiger Lily? Frank wasn't able to help with any of the specifics of the different versions but he offered the following and said I could share it with you all here…

I was also disappointed that there were no "special features" on the disk. Seems to me it would be smart to include some audio commentary by the people who were there — me, Len Maxwell, Louise — since we're still alive and lucid. Woody, of course, would not participate but the rest of us have stories to tell, you can be sure, mostly arguing about who wrote what, in all likelihood. "Did you think it was funny? Then I wrote it."

In any event, the "production" of that film was such a debacle it's a wonder there aren't more versions. At one point, for instance, after we'd dubbed in the studio for three months (!), I was in Paris on a Discovery shoot and got a telegram asking me to rent studio space and record a dozen or so new lines. I dutifully did and then when Woody, Louise and I went up the 79th Street Loew's to see it (on the bottom half of a double bill) the same lines were dubbed by Pat Harrington Jr., thus causing no end of confusion about who Phil Moscowitz is. That, I think, is the first and last time Woody has ever seen one of his films in a theatre. Or anywhere else.

If he'd seen it in the theater where I saw it, he'd probably have given up filmmaking and gone into the sheet metal business. It was paired on a double-feature with some dreary, badly-lit foreign film with subtitles that didn't quite make it onto the bottom of the screen. When Tiger Lily finally came on, my friends and I were the only ones laughing…and even we stopped because we didn't want to wake up the other patrons. I didn't really like the movie until I saw it on home video…but the sloppiness of the production was evident, and I recall not being able to fully track which voice went with which character. Ah, well.

The show Frank mentions — Discovery — was a wonderful science/information show that he hosted on ABC in '62 and '63. It belied the notion that educational shows are boring. I actually remember my friends and I putting down the comic books and turning on Channel 7 when it was time for Discovery and I still occasionally come up with a fact that I'm sure I learned from that program. Even more entertaining was a show that he did for NBC in 1970 with my associate Lee Mendelson. It was called Hot Dog and it starred Jonathan Winters, Jo Anne Worley and Woody Allen. The show was about how things are made and what they'd do was to ask a question — "How do they make spaghetti?" "How is money printed?" — and then go to the panel of experts who would make up ridiculous explanations. Then they'd show us the real answer. It was very amusing and Lee keeps threatening to take them off the shelf and syndicate them again. If he ever does, you'll love them.

Anyway, thanks, Frank. As you can all see, news from me gets results. In addition to being Fair and Balanced.

Comics in Court

Here's an article about the conviction of Jesus Castillo. He's the comic book shop manager in Dallas who was found guilty of selling an adult comic book to an adult. The article provides a good overview of the case from one perspective.

For another, take a look at this weblog entry. Houston lawyer William J. Dyer believes that folks are overreacting to many aspects of the decision. He also thinks the big problem was that Castillo's lawyer erred at a couple of key points.

A Thought About the Blackout

You know…if this happened in California, I think people would drag Gray Davis out of the governor's mansion and beat him to death.

Fox Vs. Franken

Here is the actual text of the lawsuit that Fox News has filed against Al Franken for co-opting (or ridiculing, as the case may be) their phrase, "fair and balanced." You'll need Adobe Acrobat Reader installed in order to read a document which suggests that the Fox guys were more interested in insulting Franken than in winning their point.

With Franken's as-yet-unreleased book topping the charts at Amazon, we are reminded of the time The Bullwinkle Show featured a storyline about a hat called The Kurward Derby. TV personality Durward Kirby announced his intention to sue. Bullwinkle producer Jay Ward immediately announced that he would pay all of Kirby's legal expenses to do so. "The publicity," he said, "would be worth a fortune to me." (Kirby, alas, never filed…)

Recommended Viewing (online)

If you have 6 minutes and 17 seconds (and RealPlayer installed), here's the link to Tracey Ullman's guest spot on The Daily Show With Jon Stewart. This is a funny woman.

More DVD on DVD

Daniel Frank points out to me that the second season of The Dick Van Dyke Show on DVD is scheduled for release on the same date as the first one. Great! Here's a link to order that one from Amazon. Or order both on the same visit there and I still get a cut.

All of the listings say that this one contains a whole bunch of extras plus 31 episodes, but they do not list the 31 episodes. This raises an eyebrow or two because there were actually 33 episodes of The Dick Van Dyke Show in its second season. If anyone can shed any light on this, shed it in this direction.

Also: I see that the same DVD company (Image Entertainment) has just brought out Woody Allen's What's Up, Tiger Lily? on DVD. There don't seem to be any extras on this, which is a shame. Would have been nice if they could have given us Alternate Audio with the original soundtrack.

Since I mentioned Daniel Frank: Over on his fine weblog, he points out that one thing which has delayed the SCTV episodes on home video (and even killed some of their televised reruns) has been a problem with music clearances. When you use someone else's song on a TV show, you have to clear the use of it, which can sometimes be complicated, especially if you want to use the song in an odd context or with parody lyrics. In some cases, parody lyrics are absolutely forbidden. Back when I wrote variety shows (back when there were variety shows) we often had to drop a sketch because we couldn't clear a certain song. I remember, at least back in the eighties, the Music Clearance people would laugh at you if you asked about doing anything odd with a Gershwin song or something from the Lerner and Loewe catalog. One of them said to me when I inquired, "I don't even have to make that call. The answer is always no. You use it exactly as written or you don't use it."

Or sometimes, a given song would just be too expensive. At least back then and probably still, Johnny Carson's famous theme song cost four or five times the going rate for a few bars of a comparable tune. That is why, when you see folks impersonate Carson, they so rarely use that song. (In the Saturday Night Live segments where Dana Carvey played Carson, they always skipped the monologue and started with a bit at the desk, as if returning from a commercial. That was, at least in part, because you couldn't do the show's opening without the theme and even NBC didn't want to pay the fee.)

Anyway, the relevance of all this to SCTV is that on at least a couple of episodes, I recall seeing them do something silly with a Gershwin tune, and they once did a parody of My Fair Lady. I asked one of our old Music Clearance people how they could get away with those, and the reply was, "They don't ask." Which is admirable in some ways but not others.

Candidates for Governor

Neither comic book dealer Barry Short nor comedian-writer Don Novello appear on the final list of candidates for Governor.

A shame, really. One or both might have brought some dignity to the proceedings.

Recommended Reading

Salon interviews political cartoonist Tom Tomorrow. And when you're done there, pop on over to Tom's website, which I've just decided is our Comic Art Webite of the Day.

Recommended Reading

Admittedly going out on a limb, Michael Tomasky of The American Prospect predicts that Cruz Bustamante will defeat Arnold Schwarzenegger. I think he's wrong but I think Tomasky is out on an interesting limb, and the reasons he gives as to why Arnold won't win are probably valid reasons why he won't win by much.

Then again, I still think it's too early to count out Gallagher.

DVD is Coming to DVD

Speaking of The Dick Van Dyke Show: Those of you who know it mainly as a comic book will be excited to know that there was a TV show, as well, and that the entire first season is coming out on DVD. The set, which is set for release October 21, features 30 episodes: "The Sick Boy and the Sitter," "The Meershatz Pipe," "Jealousy," "Sally and the Lab Technician," "Washington vs. the Bunny," "Oh How We Met the Night That We Danced," "The Unwelcome Houseguest," "Harrison B. Harding of Camp Crowder MO," "My Blonde-Haired Brunette," "Forty-Four Tickets," "Tell or Not to Tell," "Sally Is a Girl," "Empress Carlotta's Necklace," "Buddy Can You Spare a Job?," "Who Owes Who What?," "Sol and the Sponsor," "The Curious Thing About Women," "Punch Thy Neighbor," "Where Did I Come From?," "The Boarder Incident," "A Word a Day," "The Talented Neighborhood," "Father of the Week," "The Twizzle," "One Angry Man," "Where You Been Fassbinder?," "The Bad Old Days," "I Am My Brother's Keeper," "The Sleeping Brother" and "The Return of Happy Spangler."

There are a few lesser episodes in there and a much lower batting average than they'd have in subsequent years. Most in the cast thought "The Twizzle" was the worst show they ever did with "The Bad Old Days" a close second. But I really liked some of these, especially "Oh How We Met the Night That We Danced," "Empress Carlotta's Necklace," "Buddy Can You Spare a Job?," "The Curious Thing About Women," "Where Did I Come From?" and "The Return of Happy Spangler." And as Winston Churchill once said, even poor Dick Van Dyke Show is better than no Dick Van Dyke Show at all.

You can pre-order the collection from Amazon (and give this site a tiny cut) by clicking here.

And don't close that wallet just yet. According to this report, the first collection of the SCTV shows will be coming out in January. In this case, they won't be starting with Season #1 but with the later, stronger shows. In this case, since some of the early SCTV programs were pretty weak (and light on the stars we associate with SCTV), I think this is a good idea.

Recommended Reading

Texas schools have reported a record low instance of students "dropping-out." How have they managed this? By lying about the numbers. Here's a report on one of those things that ought to become a big issue but probably won't.

Fair and Balanced

This coming Friday is Fair and Balanced Day on weblogs all across the Internet. But of course, it's always Fair and Balanced Day here.

Freberg Article!

Good article by John Rogers about Stan Freberg. (Minor quibbles: Friz Freleng's name is spelled wrong, and Chuck Jones was always diligent about correcting people who cited him as the creator of Bugs Bunny. Other than that, good piece.)