Earlier this morning, something that was said reminded me of this story so I told it and the person to whom I told it said, "Hey, I don't think you've ever told that one on your blog!" I said, "Sure I have," but when I later did a search here, I couldn't find it. So here it is…
As you probably know, I enjoy hosting panels at comic conventions and have done, by actual count, about ninety-four gazillion of them. This story occurred during the time that the first few issues of Groo the Wanderer comics by Sergio Aragonés and Yours Truly were coming out…so around 1984. From it, I learned a valuable lesson.
A gent staging a one-day comic convention here in Southern California called Sergio and asked if the two of us would be guests. That meant that we'd sit behind a table all day and sign copies of our comics for no money. The "no money" part didn't bother me and it still doesn't except when dealers bring half the press run for signatures that will theoretically raise the resale value of the books a smidge. But I just don't like signing my name all day and if I sit next to Sergio, the line extends well into some adjacent zip code. Then I'm expected to sign as much as he does and as swiftly, which is just not humanly possible.
Sergio said yes on behalf of us both, which was fine, and then the convention organizer called me to double-check and to also ask if while I was there, would I be willing to host a panel? I agreed and he said he'd would arrange everything including what the panel would be about and who'd be on it…and I'll tip the valuable lesson of this story before we get to it. The valuable lesson of this story is NEVER AGREE TO THAT.
But I did. I have since learned that I need to have some say as to what a panel will be about, who the panelists will be and — and this is vital — how many panelists there will be. I've found that six is usually the max for a one-hour panel. If you have more time, you might accommodate seven. If you have too many, some or all of your panelists will sit for long stretches of time without being able to say anything. They'll get bored and when your panelists are getting bored, so will your audience.
Our story now jumps ahead to the day of the con…
Sergio and I arrived at the hotel with me having no idea what panel I'd be hosting, when and where it would take place or who'd be on it. The con organizer — a genial fellow who was trying to do a hundred and eleven things all at once, greeted us warmly, showed us to our signing table and then he handed me a copy of a printed program for the day's festivities. He then scurried off to attend to some of those hundred and ten other things and I looked at the program he'd handed me. It was quite informative.
From it, I discovered that at 2 PM in Room I-don't-remember, I was moderating a panel on the works of the eminent science-fiction writer, Robert Heinlein. There was also a list of ten panelists who'd be appearing to discuss this man's reknowned body of writing. Instantly, I saw two problems with this…
- I had never heard of any of these panelists and…
- I had never read anything written by Robert Heinlein.
Neither of these seemed like insurmountable problems. I assumed the panelists would all be familiar with Mr. Heinlein's work so I could have them each introduce themselves and then answer questions like, "Which of his many books is your favorite and why?" or "If someone was unfamiliar with Heinlein's work, where in his oeuvre would you suggest they start?"
"Oeuvre" is an excellent word for a situation like this because it makes you sound like you know a lot of things even when all you know is the definition of the word "oeuvre." In case you don't, it means "the works of a painter, composer or author regarded collectively." Remember that. It may come in handy someday when you have to fake knowing something about something.
And lest you think I'm a Neanderthal for not have read extensively the works of Mr. Heinlein (i.e., his "oeuvre"), let me say this: I read lots of science-fiction, mainly when I was in my teens and early twenties, but there are a lot of great books in this world that fall outside that genre. You just can't get around to all of them and I never got around to Heinlein and still haven't. But I figured that would be okay for this panel because my ten panelists would have, right?
No, not right. Because as I found out when I got to the panel room a little before 2 PM and met them all, to continue our numbering…
- Not one of the panelists had ever read anything written by Robert Heinlein and…
- They were all mystified as to why the hell they were put on this panel which they knew no more about in advance than I did.
By the time I realized the magnitude of this problem, it was 2 PM and the room had filled with about 40 people. I decided to just go ahead with the panel. It might be a total disaster but, hey, that can be entertaining. Sometimes. So I quietly told each panelist that I'd start by asking them who they were and what they'd done and to please not mention their total unfamiliarity with the works of Robert Heinlein.

Then I welcomed the audience, introduced myself and had each panelist introduce himself or herself without mentioning you-know-what. Then I asked the audience, "How many of you have read books by Robert Heinlein?" And you can probably guess what the response was…
- No one raised a hand.
Not a one. Not one person in that room — in the audience or on the stage — had read anything by Robert Heinlein. A lady who worked for the hotel came by to fill up water glasses for each of us and I'd bet my house that she hadn't read anything by Robert Heinlein either.
I asked why they'd come to a panel about Robert Heinlein and a couple of them said things like "I saw there was this panel and decided to see what it was all about." I asked if anyone had any questions about Robert Heinlein and one guy said, "Yeah, who is he?"
That's when I said, "Okay, as moderator, I declare this is no longer the Robert Heinlein panel. It's now the "Let's talk about anything that interests us" panel. Ask about anything you like — comics, TV shows, movies, famous Bar Mitzvahs, people named Arnie…anything. Someone on this panel may know something about it." The first question was, "What table is Sergio signing at?" That one, even I could handle.
Then someone asked a question about Groo and I could field that one, too. Someone on the panel had said they were writing mystery novels and they were asked a question about writing mystery novels. Someone else asked about having to write when one isn't in the mood and that was a good question — the kind I should have asked — because everyone on the panel was a writer of some sort. The whole panel suddenly turned into a panel about professional writing and getting into the mood to write and/or deal with know-nothing editors or making a living as a writer…and it turned into a pretty good panel.
There was no further mention of Mr. Heinlein. But I did manage to work the word "oeuvre" into my answers once or twice.
When it was over, I returned to the table where Sergio and I were signing. He was way ahead of me and I spent the rest of the afternoon trying and failing to catch up. Later, as the convention was closing down, the organizer came by to thank us and he asked me how the panel went. I told him it went okay and then asked, "Why did you decide there should be a panel about Robert Heinlein?"
He responded in the tone of voice you'd use if a child asked you what 2+2 equals. He said, "Because he's the greatest writer who ever lived, of course."
I asked him if he'd thought to ask any of us if we'd ever read Heinlein and he answered, "I didn't have to. You're all professional writers so naturally, you've read everything he ever wrote. Was there a problem?"
I said, "Well, since none of us had ever read anything by Robert Heinlein, yes, there was a bit of a problem."
He said, "Well then, that's on you. Hey, if you guys parked in the lot outside, let me have your ticket and I'll have it validated for you."