Joe Sinnott, R.I.P.

If you were in a crowd of folks who worked in the comic book industry and announced, "Joe Sinnott was the best inker who ever worked in comics," you wouldn't get a lot of argument. If you said, "Joe Sinnott was the nicest guy who ever worked in comics," you'd get even less.

He was not only a great inker, he was the guy who elevated that craft to an art; the guy who taught everyone else how it should be done. Almost every one of his peers studied what he did. Almost every one of his peers was told by some editor, at one time or another, "Try to do it more like Sinnott."

I met Joe via correspondence before I met him in person at the 1970 New York Comic Con. He couldn't have been nicer. A little later, I was sitting with Wally Wood, another fine artist whose work was much-admired and studied. Joe walked by and Wally asked me who that was. I told him it was Joe Sinnott. Wood, who'd done a lot of inking of Jack Kirby's art in his day, said, "That's the guy who inked Jack the way Jack should be inked. If I ever get another chance to, I want to do it like he does."

Joe was such a good inker, you forgot how good he was as an artist, doing it all himself. His photo-realistic style shouldn't have blended so well with such a wide range of pencil artists but it did. He always understood what they were trying to achieve on the page and what he should do to try and help them get there.

Joe Sinnott was born October 16, 1926 in Saugerties, New York, a city that would be his "home town" for his entire life. He grew up in a boarding house that catered primarily to teachers, several of whom saw talent in the young man's attempts to draw and encouraged him in that direction. He studied art in high school and also while in the Navy where he served in Okinawa during World War II. When he was discharged in 1946, he worked in a rock quarry for a few years before deciding it was time to resurrect his ambitions towards drawing.

Thanks to the G.I. Bill, he was able to attend the Cartoonists and Illustrators School (later known as the School of Visual Arts) in New York, where his work caught the eye of the school's co-founder, Burne Hogarth, and one of its main instructors, Tom Gill. Gill was drawing westerns and movie adaptations for Dell Comics and Sinnott spent nine months assisting him before deciding he was ready to solo.

His first job on his own was for St. John Comics but he soon broke in at Atlas (now Marvel) drawing war, western and horror comics for editor Stan Lee. Lee liked Sinnott's crisp style and the fact that the work was always well-researched and in on time. Joe later worked for other publishers including Treasure Chest, Charlton and Archie, but his main work was for Marvel, especially after Stan discovered how well Joe could ink the work of other artists.

Joe really got noticed as an inker for the pencil art of Jack Kirby. He inked several early, pre-superhero stories by Kirby and when the "Marvel Age" began, handled several key tales, including the first Thor story in Journey Into Mystery and the debut of Dr. Doom in Fantastic Four #5. Joe also drew the Thor strip for a time. Stan wanted Joe to ink as much as possible for Marvel but at the time, the company's low rates forced Joe to turn him down. Finally though, the pay was raised and Joe abandoned his Archie inking to work full-time for Marvel.

Jack Kirby and Joe Sinnott.  Joe's on the right.

Some would call him Kirby's best inker. Even though he didn't meet Jack until years after their major collaborations, he understood the way Kirby drew and knew how to separate the planes of a drawing and make Kirby's special brand of forced perspective work to maximum effect.

Joe inked almost every major Marvel artist at one time or another and kept Fantastic Four consistent through a succession of different pencilers after Kirby. At times, he made their best artists like John Buscema and Gene Colan look great. Editors also knew that Sinnott could raise the quality of weak penciling (or finish sparsely-penciled art) and assigned him to those jobs.

No matter what they threw his way, Joe made it look good and always got it in on time. Always. No editor ever had a problem with Joe Sinnott. No editor didn't wish he had a lot more Joe Sinnotts at his disposal.

The Thing and Joe Sinnott. Joe's on the right.

I've met darn near every major writer and artist who worked in comics from the sixties through the eighties. I never met a nicer man than Joe Sinnott, and few who were as inarguably good at what they did. Joe was a gentleman in every sense of the word. I could cite dozens of examples but this one will do…

In 1975 at a comic convention in New York, we made plans to meet for lunch. Just before we were about to leave the con and head across the street, a fan asked Joe for an autograph. Then another asked and another. The requests escalated into quick sketches and soon, Joe was mobbed by folks who loved his work and simply had to have a little Thor or Thing drawing from the great Joe Sinnott. After several dozen of these had delayed our lunch departure by close to an hour, I waded into the throng to play Bad Guy, stop the sketching and drag Joe off to eat.

He declined. He didn't want to disappoint all the people who were swarming around him, some of whom had been waiting for that entire hour. At his behest, my friends and I went to lunch without him. I brought him back a burger and found him in the same place, still sketching for fans. Three hours later, he was still at it and the hamburger was stone cold and untouched. If the convention hadn't kicked everyone out and closed that room, he'd probably still be there.

That was the Joe Sinnott I knew. Like I said, I never knew anyone nicer. I miss all these great artists who are, way too often, the subject of obits on this page but I'm really going to miss Joe. He died peacefully this morning at 8:40am at the age of 93, beloved by all who knew the man and his work.

Today's Video Links

Jon Stewart is making the rounds plugging his new movie and here are two of his many appearances. First, here he is going on a British TV show to talk about the film and not saying much about it. But he says some interesting things about what's going on in this country…

And here he is, phoning it in from the same room on Pod Save America

Today's Video Link

When my buddy Frank Ferrante isn't transforming himself into You-Know-Who, he often morphs into a gentleman who's a little hard to describe. Any time you're in the same room with Caesar, you're at a party. What kind of party is it? That's also a little hard to describe but he always makes you feel like you're the Guest of Honor but all the attention should be on him.

Caesar has just started his own web series. Here's Episode One of All Hail Caesar: An American Love Story

A Useful Article

What kind of a mask should you be wearing to protect you from the virus? Here's what Kaleigh Rogers has to say.

Voting Irregularities

Something weird happened with the online voting for this year's Eisner Awards. I don't exactly understand if it was Russian hacking or something having to do with Hillary's e-mails but erring on the safe side, the administrators have decided to do as follows: They've tossed out ballots that might be in question and they're sending new invites to vote to all who cast those in-question ballots. You may be receiving one and if you do, your deadline to vote anew is June 30, 2020 at 11:59 PM Pacific time.

Keep that deadline in mind and also remember that Walt Kelly's Pogo, Vol. 6: Clean as a Weasel is nominated in the category of Best Archival Collection/Project — Strips. In fact, don't just remember that. Do something with that information.

Dispatches From the Fortress – Day 105

A recurring topic on this blog is the foolishness of those who argue against rules with folks who have no power to change or override them…what I call "Dead-End Complaining." You may or may not be right that the law or rule you're expected to follow is stupid but you're wasting your time, breath and indignity to argue the point here and now.

This morning on my way home from an insignificant doctor visit, I stopped off at a market for a few edible necessities. My way into said market was blocked by an argument — a lady was screeching at a store employee, insisting she couldn't legally be denied entrance even though she wasn't wearing a mask and never would. The employee was adamant that she could.

By now, I've lost track if this is a state law or a city law or just this chain's law. It may be all three but it's still No Shoes, No Shirt, No Mask, No Entrance…and in this case, No Groceries. Me, I think it's a wise law but even if it isn't, she was arguing with someone whose job was to enforce that rule, not make exceptions. The man even had a little plastic envelope of single-use disposable masks and was quite willing to provide her with one…

…but no. That would not do. "I'm not going to be on one of those sheeple," she kept saying…and I don't know about you but I've never seen that insult hurled by anyone who wasn't a sheeple (by their own definition) listening to a different shepherd. I listened to a little of the argument then politely asked if they could move it to one side so some of us masked lambs could get in before the rotisserie chickens were all gone.

She whirled towards me and said, "Don't you feel stupid wearing that mask?" I said, "No, because of it, I'm way less likely than you to get the coronavirus and way more likely to get a half-dozen russet potatoes and some parmigiano reggiano. All you're going to do is get yourself on YouTube for all eternity screaming like a maniac."

I pointed to some other shoppers who had their cell phones out shooting her and one of them said, "Smile for the camera, lady!" Then I went in and did my shopping and when I came out, she was gone.

Let me know if you see her on YouTube. She was about 5'2" with hair that looked like Professor Irwin Corey's and eyes that were so closely set together, there was ample room for a third eye on her face. Oh — and she was wearing a Trump 2020 t-shirt but you probably guessed that.

This Evening

In a few hours, I'll be doing an online conversation with my buddy of 40 years, Jim Brochu. Jim is the person in the above photo who isn't Carl Reiner, Mel Brooks or Charlotte Rae. He's a director, a writer, an actor and an all-around entertainer, mostly these days in live theater. He also knows just about everyone in show business who I don't know and vice-versa.

At a party, I am usually confident that no one present has a better supply of show biz anecdotes but that's because Jim lives in New York. You will enjoy hearing about his life, his career and all the amazing folks he's known. We start at 7 PM Pacific and it should be viewable right here or over at www.newsfromme.tv.

Today's Video Link

Two days ago in this message, I said: "I'm waiting for the commercial that the Lincoln Project group must be making even as I type this, probably featuring that quote of Trump's about ordering that the testing be slowed down. If you were running for public office, you'd pray for your opponent to say something in front of a camera that was as self-destructive as that."

And sure enough, here it is…

How could this be worse? Maybe if he'd said, "Slow the testing down! It's making me look bad and hurting my poll numbers and that's way more important than saving lives and actually getting rid of this damned virus!"

His handlers tried to say he didn't mean it; that he was just making a joke. It must be awful working for that man because he always undercuts his own people. Today, he was asked if he was joking and he replied, "I don't kid." It's starting to look like he's bet an awful lot of money on a Biden victory.

Today's Video Link

Here's how one Las Vegas buffet has been retooled for a pandemic world. Even though we see a lot of yummy-looking food being served, this has strangely little appeal to me. (I also with my reduced-size stomach cannot possibly eat enough at any buffet to make it worth $48.99 to me.)

As I look at restaurants reopening with spread-out tables, masked servers, temperature checks, etc., I see nowhere I want to go.  I also don't want to ride on an airplane with all the new rules and the possibility for infection., I can't imagine being comfortable enough at a show to enjoy the show.  I understand of course why businesses want to reopen and folks who've depleted their savings (or have none) want to get back to work.  I just have no desire to reopen me…

For Those Who Wrote Me To Ask…

Earlier today, I posted the lineup of panelists for the Cartoon Voices Panel I'm hosting this coming Saturday.

Back on May 30, I did one that had to be aborted in progress. It was the afternoon that my neighborhood was filled with protesters and looters and police officers and reporters. Those four kinds of folks should not be confused with one another. There were also more helicopters overhead than you'd see if you watched every episode of the M*A*S*H TV show and counted every chopper you saw on screen, including repeats in the opening titles.

The Internet service in my area went kablooey on me that day and we had to shut down the panel. I have decided to pretend it never existed. You will not find what we did on YouTube or anywhere else.

So now I'm back doing them again starting this Saturday. Many people are writing to ask why most of the panelists on this one aren't the panelists who were on that one and will those panelists be on future ones?

Yes. I expect to do three in the month of July, one of which is already recorded and will debut in connection with Comic-Con International's Comic-Con at Home project. The others who were on the Incredible Disappearing Cartoon Voices Panel will be on one of these panels by the end of July, assuming they're available. On July 11, I'll be doing one and so far, I have the guy who did The Brain on Pinky & The Brain, the lady who did Jimmy Neutron on Jimmy Neutron: Boy Genius and the fellow who does The Whammy on the current version of Press Your Luck.

And I'm doing some other panels for Comic-Con at Home including, yes, The Annual Jack Kirby Tribute Panel. I've gotten so accomplished at hosting panels, I can now do it without even leaving my house.

Happy Floyd Norman Day!

Photo by Bruce Guthrie
Photo by Bruce Guthrie

Floyd Norman began his cartooning career assisting Bill Woggon, artist of the Katy Keene comic books. In 1956, he got a job as an in-betweener (an assistant animator) at the Walt Disney Studio where he started by working on Sleeping Beauty. He was the first black artist to work there and he subsequently applied his talents to other Disney films, including One Hundred and One Dalmatians, The Sword in the Stone and The Jungle Book, moving from animation to the story department in the process.

He has not spent his career exclusively at Disney — though he worked there enough to be named a Disney Legend in 2007. He popped up at almost every animation studio in town — I met him at Hanna-Barbera — and even co-ran a studio for a time. (It was Vignette Films, which among its other projects did a lot of the early animation for Sesame Street and produced the first Fat Albert cartoon for Bill Cosby.) He's one of those guys who's done just about everything in animation. He's also an incredibly nice, clever guy.

I ran this item and photo five years ago here to wish Floyd a happy 80th birthday. I'm running it again today to wish him a happy 85th and I intend to run it when he's 90 and when he's 95, as well. If and when he makes it to a hundred, I'll come up with a new item and a new photo. You can get a lot of re-use with a guy who never seems to age.

Recommended Reading

The two online pundits I follow most often who write about foreign policy are the somewhat-Liberal Fred Kaplan and the somewhat-Conservative Daniel Larison. When they agree on something, as they sometimes do, I feel I have stumbled upon something that's as close to the truth as you're ever likely to find on the Internet.

The two men have both now reviewed John Bolton's new book, The Room Where It Happened, which contains the testimony he could have given under oath, transcribed and published to achieve profit and avoid cross-examination. It's less useful to the country that way but it's not without its value

Here's a bit of what Daniel Larison had to say…

Bolton thinks he is scoring a huge hit by saying that Mnuchin worried more about how a policy affects Americans than the "mission" of regime change, which just drives home how fanatical and bad for America Bolton's foreign policy obsessions are. If we learn anything from Bolton's book, it is that Bolton was a terrible and dangerous National Security Advisor, and the country is better off now that he will never again serve in government. But then, like most of the other things contained in the book, we already knew that.

And here's Fred Kaplan

The Room Where It Happened (out Tuesday) is every bit the flame job that the advance news stories indicated. But it's also, unwittingly, an indictment of Bolton himself — as warmonger, self-aggrandizer, deceiver, at times a shrewd bureaucratic operator, at other times stunningly blind to the politics around him, and, in any case, a man that no future president should hire to walk his dog, much less help guard the nation.

Don't those two paragraphs sound like they were written by the same guy?

Dispatches From the Fortress – Day 103

A quick surf of Ye Olde Internet this morning shows me lots of stories about how many cities are allowing the reopening of businesses and how many cities that have are reporting record numbers of new COVID-19 cases. I understand but do not necessarily agree with the argument that remaining largely closed down may do more damage than keeping down the virus numbers. For the time being, I'm going to continue to disagree with that argument and stay here in the Fortress of Solitude. My friend Ken Levine well summarizes why you won't find me rushing out to dine in a favorite restaurant.

And my friend Paul Harris well summarizes how I feel about John Bolton. What Paul wrote is short enough that I'm going to steal the whole paragraph…

It's important to remember you can hold two opposing thoughts in your head simultaneously. For instance, you can think, "John Bolton's revelations about Trump make me feel great," while you also think, "John Bolton has always been a douchebag who helped push us into war with Iraq and refused to testify to the House during its impeachment hearings."

John Bolton has always been a terrible, terrible human being who thinks we should be sending American troops to bomb (and die) everywhere. I suppose there's a smidgen of respect that unlike everyone else who cheered on the Iraq War, he's still willing to say it was a good idea and we should have done more of that. But when Bolton and Trump are calling each other names, I can only express amazement at seeing two guys who are always wrong about everything else be right about each other.

Incidentally, I'm waiting for the Lincoln Project to whip up a montage of Trump insulting all the ex-employees he proudly hired not so long ago. Then they close with a clip of him bragging how he's a great manager who only hires the best people.

And that's about all I want to write about Trump for a while. I have to write about better people (some of them, talking animals) this week.

Tomorrow evening, I'm going to be resuming my "Conversations," my one-on-one webcasts. If you come to this blog in search of showbiz stories, you will O.D. on them when Jim Brochu and I get together. I'll post a little more about Jim later today or tomorrow morning. And this Saturday, I resume my Cartoon Voices Panels online. I'll post the lineup a little later. Off to work —!